To provide you with a list of the best restaurants in Reynoldsburg, I scoured the internet, analyzed countless establishments, and compared them. In addition, I read reviews from clients and noted the overall feel of each restaurant.
Since customers are the best judges, their opinions should not be overlooked when reviewing a restaurant. The better the food and the cleaner the establishment, the more satisfied the clients are. And happy clients leave positive reviews.
Furthermore, I analyzed the prices of restaurants, specifically those serving the same type of food. Low prices do not necessarily mean that a restaurant serves low-quality food, just like the opposite is not always the case.
I was curious to see why the same food is more expensive in some restaurants. And one of the reasons is amenities. For example, one Chinese restaurant may have a lake view or an outside patio, whereas another may not; this can influence the differences in prices.
Dragon Express Kitchen
$ | 614-762-3797 | WEBSITE
View this post on Instagram
This Indian restaurant provides dine-in, take-out, and catering options. It’s open for breakfast, lunch, and dinner and positive reviews from clients place it higher than other Indian restaurants in the area.
Customers reviewed the food as flavorful, the staff attentive, and the establishment as clean and pretty.
Compared to other Indian restaurants in Reynoldsburg, the food at Dragon Express Kitchen is cheap and affordable for those who do not wish to spend too much money.
Sakana Restaurant
$ | 614-866-6160 | WEBSITE
If you’re craving Asian cuisine, Sakana is an excellent option. The restaurant serves Chinese, Thai, and Japanese dishes and offers pick-up, dine-in, and delivery options.
Sakana has many positive reviews from satisfied customers, who describe the establishment as having a pleasant atmosphere, the food as fresh and delicious, and the prices as affordable for those on a limited budget.
The restaurant is clean, cozy, and quiet. Though relatively small, Sakana has a bar and a lounge for those who choose to have a drink rather than eat.
Scali Ristorante & Deli
$$ | 614-759-7764 | WEBSITE
Open for dinner hours (5 pm to 8 pm), this family-run Italian restaurant is small and cozy, with a design that gives customers the feeling of being in Little Italy.
The restaurant offers dine-in, take-out, and delivery options and specializes in authentic Italian cuisine that has gained the appreciation of customers, who advise making a reservation beforehand.
The menu includes antipasti, pasta, specialita Della casa, desserts, and a variety of wines, all at an affordable cost. Satisfied customers have described their food as tasty and the staff as attentive.
SC Bar & Kitchen
$$ | 614-863-1004 | WEBSITE
View this post on Instagram
SC Bar & Kitchen is ideal for those over 21 who are craving hot wings or a burger with their drink. Though this establishment is primarily a sports bar, there are numerous food options from which to choose.
They serve American cuisine and offer dine-in and curbside pick-up options. Their prices are somewhat higher than those of other restaurants serving similar food, which is understandable since they are a bar.
However, customers describe the food as very good, the servers as friendly, and the bartender as very skilled.
Tacos El Fogoncito
$ | 614-626-0096 | WEBSITE
View this post on Instagram
If you’re craving Mexican, Tacos El Fogoncito is an excellent option. The restaurant offers authentic Mexican cuisine and prides itself on its specialty, Al Pastor. Their prices are affordable even for those on a tight budget, and customers reviewed the food as ‘one that never disappoints.’
You first notice the eye-catching and inviting design, which includes elements from Mexico’s history and appeals to passers-by.
The authentic food, combined with the rustic and unique aspects of the establishment, takes you back to the days of vaqueros and bandits, when people traveled everywhere by horse.
Tyler’s Pizzeria & Bakery
$ | 614-322-9587 | WEBSITE
View this post on Instagram
Tyler’s Pizzeria & Bakery is an excellent option if you’re in the mood for pizza.
The restaurant specializes in pizza, pastries, and bread and has been well-reviewed by numerous customers, earning it positive reviews from many satisfied customers, emphasized the food’s superior quality and the staff’s friendliness.
At Tyler’s pizzeria, there is an air of friendliness mixing in with the delicious smells of fresh pizza and pastries.
Inside, the restaurant has a rustic look, and out front, there are several tables and chairs for those who prefer to eat outside.
Prost Beer & Wine Cafe
$$ | 614-694-0975 | WEBSITE
Specializing in American cuisine, Prost prides itself on the superior quality of the food and drinks they serve, and customers seem to agree.
The restaurant has a unique ambiance you can notice even from outside. The numerous tables with umbrellas in front of the building do not distract from the delicious food or the variety of wine and beer.
Their prices tend to be slightly higher than those of competing businesses, but customers swear it’s worth it.
Sargam Restaurant & Bar
$$ | 614-892-7474 | WEBSITE
View this post on Instagram
Sargam specializes in Nepalese food and offers dine-in, delivery, and take-out options. The establishment is spacious and has a modern look to it.
The menu provides enough options for everyone, from main courses, such as seafood and vegetarian, to desserts, such as ras malai and mango kulfi.
Though their prices run slightly higher than those of other Nepalese restaurants outside of Reynoldsburg, according to customers, they have the lowest prices in town.
The superior quality of their food, and the inviting look of the establishment has earned this restaurant a special place in the hearts of satisfied customers, who have said they are looking forward to coming back.
Himali Heritage Cuisine & Event Center
$$ | 614-604-9843 | WEBSITE
Himali Heritage is a buffet specializing in Asian cuisine, offering options for dining-in, take-out, and catering. The establishment is spacious, and the menu includes items that both meat lovers and vegetarians can enjoy.
The positive reviews from satisfied customers have earned this establishment a good reputation in town. Satisfied customers have pointed out that the food there is delicious, the restaurant is clean, and the employees are helpful.
Vick’s Gourmet Pizza
$$ | 614-655-4422 | WEBSITE
View this post on Instagram
Up and running since 1961, this restaurant has many good reviews from satisfied customers. The menu has various options beyond pizza, with wings, subs, salads, being some of the things you can order off their extensive menu.
Reviewers have mentioned the friendliness of the staff and the variety of food options.
The establishment has a modern and unique look to it, with arcade games standing in a corner and interesting decorations on the walls. As for amenities, it has tables out back and the occasional live music.
Los Pinos
$ | 614-762-6567 | WEBSITE
The restaurant prides itself on the fact that it serves authentic Salvadorean and Mexican food. Los Pinos provides the option of dine-in, take-out, or delivery, and they are open every day of the week.
Their specialties are Los 5 Pinos, Ostiones, and Carne Asada, and customers who have reviewed this restaurant have pointed out that the food is of superior quality, the prices are affordable even for those on a tight budget, and the staff is kind.
Durbar Cuisine
$ | 614-986-9621 | WEBSITE
View this post on Instagram
Located in a small plaza on the East Main Street of the city, Durbar is one of Reynoldsburg’s hidden gems.
The restaurant serves Indian and Nepalese dishes, and customer reviews reflect the restaurant’s quality of food. The food is cheap compared to other Indian and Nepalese restaurants in town.
And though the establishment’s appearance is not something to write home about, that should not be a defining factor when deciding to eat there. The restaurant has been well received by many, who have said they definitely plan on coming back.
Asian Star China Buffet
$ | 614-856-0673 | WEBSITE
Specializing in Chinese food, Asian Star China Buffet is another hidden gem of Reynoldsburg. The restaurant offers dine-in, delivery, and catering options.
It’s open six days a week (closed on Tuesdays) and provides customers with a wide variety of foods and desserts, from chow Mein and egg foo young to shrimp, sushi, and much more.
Multiple customers positively reviewed the restaurant, and have mentioned how the quality if the food convinced them to not only return, but also tell others about the restaurant.
Though the restaurant is relatively small, its appearance is inviting, providing the option of a booth or table.
In conclusion
If you’re from Reynoldsburg and are looking for a new favorite restaurant, or you are visiting and are in search of somewhere to eat delicious food, know this – the city is not lacking in restaurants. Whether you’re craving pizza or tacos, Nepalese cuisine or a burger, Reynoldsburg has it all.
Hayden has been a digital director for years. He has five years of experience editing and writing about food, restaurant, and recipe review content. At Birch Restaurant, he’s in charge of scouting, showing up unannounced in different restaurants, and writing a thorough food guide!
