If you’re looking for the best restaurants in Willoughby, Ohio, look no further. We’ve done the research, so you don’t have to. Whether you’re craving Italian food or burgers, Willoughby has it all. Pick your cuisine, pick your ambiance, and pick a place that’s sure to please your palate!
1. Hook & Hoof New American Kitchen and Cocktail
$$ | (440) 571-5312 | WEBSITE
View this post on Instagram
The Hook & Hoof New American Kitchen and Cocktail is a warm, unpretentious outlet serving New American plates alongside cocktails, beer & wine. It’s the perfect place to enjoy a delicious meal with friends or just to get a drink after work.
The menu focuses on seasonal, local ingredients and has a nice variety of options for everyone at your party. You can choose from everything from wild-caught seasonal fresh catch with wheatberry salad or roasted root veg to double bone-in elk chop.
If you’re looking for a laidback spot that provides an inviting atmosphere while offering great food and drinks, this is the place for you!
2. The Wild Goose
$$ | (440) 951-6644 | WEBSITE
View this post on Instagram
Customers flock to this friendly, family-run bar for the wood-fired pizzas and rotating tap selection. The Wild Goose is a cozy spot with ample seating and a relaxed atmosphere, perfect for enjoying delicious wood-fired pizzas with friends.
Try the Backyard BBQ pizza, which comes with garlic oil, bbq sauce, roasted chicken, white onion, green pepper, and cheddar cheese. Or opt for their Margherita pizza, which is topped with house cheese, tomato sauce, and basil.
The Wild Goose also offers a variety of appetizers and entrees that are sure to please any appetite. In addition to their extensive beer menu featuring local brews on tap or in bottles.
3. Pranzo!
$$$ | (440) 946-7827 | WEBSITE
View this post on Instagram
Pranzo! is a cozy and classy eatery that specializes in Italian cuisine and wood-fired flatbreads. Outdoor seating can be found on the patio, where you can enjoy some fresh air and watch the world go by.
The menu at Pranzo! includes eggplant parmesan, chicken marsala, as well as other traditional Italian dishes like veal parmigiana. They also serve salads and pizza.
Pranzo! is the place to go when you’re looking for a great meal with friends and family in Willoughby. The friendly staff is always ready to help you find something that’s right for you.
4. Issho Ni Ramen, Sushi & Hibachi
$$ | (440) 306-8020 | WEBSITE
View this post on Instagram
If you’re looking for a place with authentic Japanese food, Issho Ni Ramen, Sushi & Hibachi is your spot.
The menu offers a wide selection of sushi rolls and hibachi dishes, as well as ramen bowls. The restaurant is known for its friendly service and delicious food, which makes it the perfect spot to grab a bite before or after a night out on the town in Willoughby.
Issho Ni’s customer service is second to none. The staff here cares about your happiness and will answer any and all of your inquiries and make sure you have a great time at their restaurant.
5. The River Tavern
$ | (440) 946-6699 | WEBSITE
If you’re looking for the perfect restaurant to eat with friends and family, The River Tavern is the place for you. The restaurant is located in Willoughby, Ohio, and specializes in American bar food. They have a wide variety of drinks and appetizers that are sure to please everyone in your group.
Furthermore, The River Tavern offers more than just great food and drink. They also have trivia nights, karaoke, live entertainment, rib night on Tuesdays, and taco deals on Thursdays.
Finally, the staff at The River Tavern is friendly and courteous, ensuring that each guest has an enjoyable experience while dining at their establishment.
6. Kleifeld’s Restaurant
$ | (440) 942-7646 | WEBSITE
Kleifeld’s Restaurant is a classic American restaurant in Willoughby. It’s known for its excellent food and big portions, as well as its friendly service.
Kleifeld’s is a great place to get breakfast or lunch. The restaurant serves up everything from omelets to sandwiches at the counter. If you’re looking for something hearty, try their Country Fried Steak smothered in brown gravy, served with mashed potatoes and green beans.
7. Sugar Bowl
$ | (440) 525-5999 | WEBSITE
One of the best restaurants in Willoughby, that’s both affordable and delicious is Sugar Bowl.
Sugar Bowl is a restaurant with an extensive menu of Asian food and appetizers such as pho and dumplings. The restaurant also has a bakery in the restaurant that sells cute desserts.
The prices at Sugar Bowl are very affordable, so you can feel free to try any dish on their menu without breaking the bank.
8. Nora’s Public House
$$ | (440) 571-4640 | WEBSITE
They have a menu that combines traditional Irish and American dishes in a way that is entirely its own.
They offer monthly live entertainment and the largest dog-friendly patio in Downtown Willoughby in addition to their 19 taps of local and artisan brews, 20 TVs, and a wide variety of Irish Whiskey. Their goal is to give excellent service in a warm and welcoming setting.
9. Young’s Sushi
$$ | (440) 951-0002 | WEBSITE
Young’s Sushi is a great place to eat in Willoughby. The cuisine at this laid-back Japanese eatery includes rolls, sashimi, and party plates.
The service is friendly and welcoming, and the staff is very hospitable. Parking is easy, which makes it the ideal spot for dinner with friends or family. The sushi is fresh and delicious, not to mention there are plenty of options if you’re looking for something other than raw fish!
10. Sol
$$ | (440) 918-1596 | WEBSITE
View this post on Instagram
Sol is a restaurant that takes you on a culinary adventure across the world. With its rustic atmosphere and decor, it’s easy to forget that you’re in Ohio.
In a converted railroad substation, Sol offers guests a variety of small meals from across the world and handcrafted cocktails. If you’re looking for something light, try the Baja Pork Tacos or Pulled Chicken Tacos.
If you’re craving something hearty, try their Fried Pickle Burger or Tonkatsu Torta. Whatever you choose, you won’t be disappointed!
11. Ballantine
$$ | (440) 942-5151 | WEBSITE
View this post on Instagram
If you’re in Willoughby, and looking for a great place to grab a bite to eat, Ballantine is the place to be.
This gastropub has an atmosphere that’s casual and welcoming, with wood-fired pies and New American cuisine that are sure to please any palate. You can also enjoy craft beers from around the world and Belgium-style brews.
Our favorite thing about Ballantine is their happy hour deals on food and drinks. In addition to being delicious, the prices are very reasonable for the quality and portion size.
12. Panini’s Bar and Grill
$$ | (440) 951-9852 | WEBSITE
View this post on Instagram
Panini’s Bar and Grill is a cafe that many locals love for its relaxed atmosphere and casual dining experience. They’re known for their sandwiches, burgers, and other comfort food, as well as their cocktails and beer.
One of the most popular items on their menu is their Turkey Stack, which comes with melted American cheese, applewood bacon, and tomato on grilled 9-grain bread.
Takeaway
We hope you’ve enjoyed our list of the best restaurants in Willoughby. It can be challenging to find good food when you’re traveling, so we wanted to make sure you were eating at places that would impress your friends and family.
Hayden has been a digital director for years. He has five years of experience editing and writing about food, restaurant, and recipe review content. At Birch Restaurant, he’s in charge of scouting, showing up unannounced in different restaurants, and writing a thorough food guide!
