We’ve compiled a list of the Best Restaurants in St Augustine. Whether you’re looking for a romantic dinner spot, a place to enjoy some local seafood, or just want to find the best eats in town, this list has you covered.
You can trust every restaurant on this list is worth a visit. They’re tried and true favorites, beloved by locals and visitors alike. If you’re in St. Augustine, don’t miss a chance to dine at one (or more!) of these great restaurants.
Harry’s Seafood, Bar & Grille
$$ | (904) 824-7765 | WEBSITE
If you’re looking for a delicious seafood meal in St. Augustine, Harry’s Seafood, Bar & Grille is the perfect spot. The restaurant offers a wide variety of seafood dishes, all of which are cooked to perfection.
Whether you’re in the mood for fresh fish, shrimp, crab, or lobster, Harry’s has something to offer. Harry’s stands out thanks to its New Orleans-style cooking, giving the menu a twist with dishes like jambalaya and signature cocktails.
The prices are also very reasonable, making Harry’s a great option for budget-minded diners. Be sure to try the gumbo, it’s simply amazing.
Catch 27
$$ | (904) 217-3542 | WEBSITE
View this post on Instagram
If you’re looking for a seafood restaurant in St. Augustine, you’ll want to check out Catch 27. The menu features fresh, local seafood and the dishes are inventive and delicious.
The service is excellent and the atmosphere is casual yet refined. Everything is made from scratch and all seafood served at Catch 27 is freshly caught. This is a great spot for a date night or dinner with family and friends.
The best part about Catch 27? The prices are very reasonable for the high quality of food and service. You’ll want to come back, again and again, to try everything on the menu. Trust us, you won’t be disappointed.
Prohibition Kitchen
$$ | (904) 209-5704 | WEBSITE
Prohibition Kitchen is one of the best and most unique restaurants in St. Augustine, Florida. This retro gastropub features an extensive menu of American comfort food with a modern twist. The dishes are all expertly prepared and beautifully presented. Most nights, you can catch live music at Prohibition Kitchen, making it the perfect spot for a night out on the town.
If you’re looking for an upscale dining experience in St. Augustine, look no further than Prohibition Kitchen. This restaurant is sure to please even the most discerning palate. Whether you’re looking for a light meal or a hearty dinner, you’ll find something to suit your taste at Prohibition Kitchen.
O’Steen’s Restaurant
$$ | (904) 829-6974 | WEBSITE
If you’re looking for the best seafood in St. Augustine, look no further than O’Steen’s Restaurant. This local favorite has been serving up fresh, delicious seafood for over 50 years. Known for it’s fried shrimp and shellfish dishes, this cash-only restaurant is definitely worth a visit.
The line can get long, but it’s well worth the wait. O’Steen’s is one of the most popular local restaurants for a reason, and you’ll have to visit it to find out what makes this hole-in-the-wall seafood joint so special.
Columbia Restaurant
$$ | (904) 824-3341 | WEBSITE
View this post on Instagram
If you’re looking for an authentic Spanish dining experience, look no further than the Columbia Restaurant. This St. Augustine institution has been serving up traditional Spanish fare for over a century.
The menu features classic dishes like paella and roast suckling pig, as well as more modern items like shrimp scampi and filet mignon. The Columbia Restaurant is the perfect spot for a romantic night out or a special celebration. The high-end restaurant makes for an unforgettable dining experience.
Be sure to try the famous flaming Spanish coffee, a must-have at the Columbia Restaurant. This delicious cocktail is made with coffee liqueur, dark rum, and fresh whipped cream. It’s then flamed tableside for a show-stopping finish. The Columbia Restaurant is one of the most memorable dining experiences in St. Augustine, Florida.
Forgotten Tonic
$$ | (904) 827-9055 | WEBSITE
View this post on Instagram
If you’re in the mood for American cuisines, whether it’s small plates or main dishes, you’re in for a treat when you dine at Forgotten Tonic.
This hip and modern gastro-pub is located near the Lightner Museum and is one of the newest restaurants in St. Augustine. The menu features unique takes on classic American dishes, as well as an expansive list of craft cocktails and beers.
The atmosphere at Forgotten Tonic is casual yet chic, making it the perfect spot for a night out with friends or a romantic dinner. The service is also top-notch, so you can expect to have a great experience from start to finish. Whether you’re looking for delicious food, killer cocktails, or both, Forgotten Tonic is sure to exceed your expectations.
Ice Plant Bar
$$ | (904 )829-6553 | WEBSITE
View this post on Instagram
If you’re looking for a unique and delicious cocktail, look no further than the Ice Plant Bar. This hip spot is located in St. Augustine Distillery, an industrial building from the 1920s, and serves up some of the best drinks in town.
The bartenders are experts at mixing up creative cocktails, and they’re always happy to make something to your liking. The Ice Plant Bar also has an extensive list of beer and wine, so there’s something for everyone.
The atmosphere at the Ice Plant Bar is industrial yet chic, with seasonal food and cocktails to take the experience at Ice Plant Bar to new heights.
Pizzalley’s Chianti Room
$$ | (904) 825-4100 | WEBSITE
View this post on Instagram
Pizzalley’s Chianti Room is an Italian restaurant located in the heart of St. Augustine’s historic district. The restaurant is situated in an old brick building, which only adds to its charm. The menu features classic Italian dishes like wood-fired pizza and pasta, as well as more modern items like chicken parmesan and lasagna.
If you’re looking for a romantic evening out, Pizzalley’s Chianti Room is the perfect place to go, with the cozy atmosphere enhanced by a beautiful veranda looking out onto St. Augustine. The restaurant has an extensive wine list and a full bar, and the staff is more than happy to help you find the perfect bottle or drink to pair with your meal.
Gas Full Service Restaurant
$$ | (904) 917-0326 | WEBSITE
If you’re in the mood for a delicious burger or some home-style cooking, Gas Full Service Restaurant is the perfect spot. The restaurant is located in an old gas station, which gives it a unique atmosphere.
The menu features classic American dishes like burgers, fries, and milkshakes, as well as more sophisticated items like filet mignon and lobster.
The focus of the menu is steak, seafood, and southern-style food complemented with craft beer. If you’re in the mood for a casual dining experience with food that goes above and beyond, Gas Full Service Restaurant is sure to please.
Llama Restaurant
$$ | (904) 819-1760 | WEBSITE
View this post on Instagram
If you’re in the mood for some Peruvian cuisine, Llama Restaurant is the perfect spot. The restaurant is located in an old brick building, which gives it a cozy and intimate atmosphere. The menu features classic Peruvian dishes like ceviche, as well as more modern items like quinoa salad and salmon.
The focus of the menu is on fresh, local ingredients and traditional cooking methods. With vegetarian options, as well as a full bar, Llama Restaurant has something everyone will enjoy as they take your taste buds beyond the restaurant and immerse you in the culinary experience of Peru.
Gaufres and Goods
$$ | (904) 829-5770 | WEBSITE
Gaufres and Goods is the best spot for some Greek and Polish food on St. Augustine’s historic downtown bayfront. The menu features a delicious variety of both sweet and savory crepes, as well as some hearty sandwiches and salads that you can’t find anywhere else.
The service is always friendly and efficient, and the food is reasonably priced. The restaurant has a charming patio area that’s perfect for people-watching on a sunny day. If you’re a beer connoisseur, Gaufres and Goods carries imported beer that you can enjoy with your meal.
Raintree Restaurant
$$$ | (904) 824-7211 | WEBSITE
View this post on Instagram
If you’re looking for an upscale dining experience in St. Augustine, look no further than Raintree Restaurant. This white-tablecloth establishment serves contemporary American cuisine with a focus on organic, locally sourced ingredients.
The menu features both small plates and entrees, so you can either share a few dishes with your dining companions or enjoy a full meal. The wine list is extensive and features both local and international wines.
The selling point for Raintree Restaurant is the location in a restored Victorian house in historic St. Augustine, making for a truly unique dining experience.
The best restaurants in St. Augustine, Florida vary in price and cuisine, but all offer a unique and memorable dining experience. Whether you’re looking for a casual spot to enjoy some crepes, an upscale restaurant with organic, locally sourced cuisine, or some international fare, there’s something for everyone in St. Augustine.
Hayden has been a digital director for years. He has five years of experience editing and writing about food, restaurant, and recipe review content. At Birch Restaurant, he’s in charge of scouting, showing up unannounced in different restaurants, and writing a thorough food guide!
You really should take a look at Cortesses Bistro in St Augustine. Recently reopened with a new owner and handmade pasta. Iur “go to” in St Augustine and we are foodies.