12 Best Restaurants in Carlisle, PA [2022 Updated]

Carlisle is a town in Cumberland County, Pennsylvania. With easy access to fresh vegetables and meat from neighbouring farms, Carlisle restaurants have distinguished their cuisine from the competition. So, begin by perusing our selection of the 12 best restaurants in Carlisle to get a head start on your culinary adventure.

Fay’s Country Kitchen

$ | (717) 243-5510 | WEBSITE

Fay's Country Kitchen

Fay’s Country Kitchen is one of Carlisle’s premier breakfast restaurants. If you’re not a fan of breakfast, this charming Coca-Cola-themed eatery can quickly alter your opinion. They provide a warm and polite service.

This helps you feel at ease while eating your food. Fay’s Country Kitchen has a delectable cuisine that includes everything from skillets and waffles to pancakes and veggies. This restaurant’s order-to-delivery time is so quick that you barely have time to sit down before your meal comes to the table.

 

Seve-N-Dots Publik Pizza Place

$$ | (717) 249-0333 | WEBSITE

Seve-N-Dots Publik Pizza Place

Located in the heart of the countryside, Seve-N-Dots serves some of the greatest pizza around. Among the many other options on the menu, their pizza is a noteworthy selection. This pizza, which is available with a variety of toppings, has a fantastic flavour and a fantastic dough.

Customers who are gluten sensitive may now get gluten-free pizza from them. This restaurant creates its dough from scratch and utilizes only fresh ingredients to create an authentic Italian flavour. The location gives you that family get-together vibe.

 

Cafe Bruges

$$ | (717) 960-0223 | WEBSITE

Café Bruges is a Belgian-style restaurant that specializes in Belgian cuisine. Speciality diets such as vegetarian and gluten-free options are also offered. A broad range of wines and beers are available to accompany the delicious moule frites, burgers, waffles, and liege salad that they provide.

There are more than 100 Belgian beers available on the menu at this establishment. In addition, the facility has the look of a café in the Belgian style. When you look inside the kitchen from the outside, you can see how clean and well-organized everything is.

 

Rustic Tavern

$$ | (717) 245-2999 | WEBSITE

Rustic Tavern

When it comes to casual lunches and dinners, the Rusty Tavern, which oozes amazing warmth, is a great choice. This pub, located on Newville Road in Carlisle, offers superb eating options, including American and seafood favourites.

Steaks, ribs, and spaghetti are just a few of the dishes on the menu. You’ll be clamouring for more of their delicious crab cakes, which are composed completely of high-quality crab meat, and the tender filet mignon will melt in your mouth because of the rich flavour it has.

There is also a fireplace and a large assortment of wines in this establishment.

 

Middlesex Diner

$ | (717) 241-2021 | WEBSITE

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Middlesex Diner (@middlesex_diner)

You should stop by Middlesex Diner if you’re in Carlisle and want to get a taste of that classic American diner experience that travellers frequently mention. Middlesex Diner is located in the heart of downtown Carlisle.

This lovely and reasonably priced restaurant serves meals in large portions from breakfast to dinner and offers a diverse selection of options that include, but are not limited to, quesadillas, gyros, and speciality sandwiches, among other things.

The service is friendly and the prices are reasonable. Even when the restaurant is completely packed, the seating arrangement gives the impression of being less crowded.

 

Momma Spriggs Restaurant

$$$ | (717) 701-8645 | WEBSITE

Momma Spriggs Restaurant

The Momma Spriggs restaurant in Carlisle will make you wish you’d discovered it sooner after your meal there. Tuesday through Saturday from 11 a.m. to 9 p.m., this stylish informal diner is closed on Mondays, but they are open for lunch and dinner from Tuesday through Saturday.

Hushpuppies and flash-fried clam strips are two appetizers that you should try out. They are really delicious.

Momma Spriggs is one of Carlisle’s most popular restaurants, thanks to the relaxing jazz music playing in the background and the wide selection of delectable dishes on the menu.

 

Issei Noodle

$ | 717-243-7826 | WEBSITE

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Issei Noodle 🍜 (@isseinoodle)

If you’re looking for the best Asian cuisine in Carlisle, look no further than Issei Noodle House. This family-owned restaurant, which is located in downtown Carlisle, prepares some of the most delectable Asian dishes you have likely ever tasted.

Asian food enthusiasts will find happiness in indulging in the culinary delicacies of Issei Noodle’s menu.

This tiny restaurant, which was named the finest in Cumberland County by the Sentinel newspaper in 2021, specialized in traditional dishes such as ramen and Vietnamese pho. Consider trying the savoury Japanese meal Yaki Udon noodles for an extra delight to tantalize your taste senses!

 

1974 The Whiskey Rebellion

$$$ | (717) 960-1000 | WEBSITE

1974 The Whiskey Rebellion

A lovely American eatery with a long and illustrious past. More than a hundred American and international whiskeys are available at 1794 The Whiskey Rebellion. There’s more to come. In the warm rustic atmosphere, you quickly feel at ease.

1794 The Whiskey Rebellion is one of Carlisle, Pennsylvania’s most highly rated restaurants, with a diverse menu to pick from. Appetizers like Amish kasespatzle and deviled duck eggs are delicious and leave you wanting more. Try the 1782 filet mignon, a delicate steak with a savoury smokey flavour that is grilled to perfection.

 

Redds Smokehouse BBQ – Carlisle

$$ | (717) 254-6419 | WEBSITE

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by ReddsBBQ (@reddsbbq)

Where do you go in Carlisle if you’re in the mood for some good old-fashioned southern barbecue? Redds Smokehouse BBQ – Carlisle is the best choice here. While this modest restaurant may not have much to offer in terms of visual appeal, it more than makes up for it by tantalizing your taste sensations.

From baby ribs to beef brisket, this establishment offers a variety of expertly-smoked meats as well as a well-seasoned barbecue sauce to go with them. If you happen to be in Carlisle, this is absolutely a destination you should include on your itinerary.

 

Hamilton Restaurant

$ | 717-249-4410 | WEBSITE

Hamilton Restaurant

Hamilton Restaurant is a comfortable diner in the heart of downtown Carlisle that welcomes families. While this restaurant is well-known for its delicious hotdogs, it also serves a variety of other delectable dishes, such as lamb chops and crab cakes.

This restaurant is open from 6 a.m. to 9 p.m. Monday through Saturday. As a result, you can eat in this restaurant at any time of day.

Make sure to try their hotchee dogs, which are a signature special meal made with mustard, onions, and a savoury sauce and are a must-try.

 

Market Cross Pub & Brewery

$$ | (717) 258-1234 | WEBSITE

The Market Cross Pub & Brewery, which was named the best pub in the area in 2015, takes its name from the town of Carlisle, England, where a Market Cross was erected in 1682 and is still in use today.

The menu includes delectable dishes from both the United Kingdom and the United States. Steak salad, fish and chips, and burgers are just a few of the many options available on the extensive menu here. In addition, there is a huge variety of fantastic ales and beers to choose from.

 

Spoons Café

$$ | (717) 793-1048 | WEBSITE

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Spoons Cafe (@_spoons_cafe_)

Spoons Café takes great pride in being a one-of-a-kind health-conscious restaurant. The meals served here are prepared using a farm-to-table philosophy, which means that no chemicals or processing are used. The restaurant is located in the heart of Carlisle’s downtown art district, and the house features two dining rooms.

Homemade soups are made from scratch and served hot only for breakfast and lunch, and they are not available for dinner. Monday through Saturday, the restaurant is open from 10.30 a.m. to 4 p.m.

In addition to soups, salads, sandwiches, and paninis are available for purchase.

 

Hickory Ridge Restaurant

$$ | (717) 906-1765 | WEBSITE

This diner is the place to go if you want an inviting atmosphere with delicious eats in a family-style restaurant.

Hickory Ridge Restaurant is open from 8 a.m. to 9 p.m. every day of the week. Kid meals are available and delicious. The servers are courteous and prompt. This fashionable eatery is well-known for its Pennsylvania slow roast, fresh-cut fries, and homemade apple butter.

If you need catering for your wedding, the caterers here with over 30 years of experience can make your event memorable.

 

Summary

There you have it. The 12 Best Restaurants In Carlisle, Pennsylvania. Whenever you find yourself in this area, do yourself a favour and stop into one of these diners. Whether you are dining alone or with family, you will always be able to find tasty and reasonably priced meals here.

Leave a Comment