11 Best Restaurants in Cape Elizabeth, ME [2022 Updated]

History, lighthouses, and shoreside parks—those are the top three things tourists often think of when they hear about Cape Elizabeth.

But you should not miss out on the best restaurants in Cape Elizabeth, ME! Not only is this sophisticated town beautiful, but it’s an ideal town to get the famous Maine lobster.

Here are the 11 best restaurants in Cape Elizabeth, ME:

The Good Table

$$ | (207) 799-4663 | WEBSITE

Best Restaurants in Cape Elizabeth, ME The Good Table

Since 1986, The Good Table has been serving Sunday brunch in town. Many locals loved this restaurant, and it grew to be one of the best restaurants in Cape Elizabeth.

But in 2001, the restaurant caught fire. Then, in no time, the owners decided to rebuild the fantastic restaurant and get back on their feet to serve the rest of the town again.

The Good Table lives up to its name. You’ll not only get good food, but you’ll experience great dining and excellent service in this place. This restaurant is just a few minutes away from Portland Headlight.

You should try The Good Table’s menu items for brunch, breakfast, lunch, or dinner if you’re visiting nearby. Try their Blackboard Specials too! You won’t regret them; that’s for sure.

 

Sea Glass

$$$$ | (207) 799-3134 | WEBSITE

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Inn by the Sea (@innbythesea.maine)

Do you want to immerse yourself in an unmatched dining experience? Head out to Sea Glass, one of the best restaurants in Cape Elizabeth. This place is breathtaking. It’s cozy and refreshing. You can dine inside its oceanfront dining room or choose a spot on its alfresco deck.

Sea Glass showcases vegan-friendly meals. Their menu consists of ethical, plant-based dishes that even those who love meat will enjoy. Sea Glass has a variety of delicious vegan meals. You’ll be surprised by the fresh flavors Sea Glass offers.

 

The Lobster Shack at Two Lights

$$ | (207) 799-1677 | WEBSITE

Next is The Lobster Shack at Two Lights. This restaurant has earned many awards and has been a favorite since the 1920s. This place has outdoor and indoor dining places open for all guests.

Dining here is a pleasant experience. You’ll get to eat at a picnic table beside the calming waters of the city. Or, you could also stay inside their dining room as you watch ships enter Portal Harbor. An exciting view of busy Maine fishers at work awaits you too!

 

Bite into Maine

$$ | (207) 289-6142 | WEBSITE

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Bite into Maine (@biteintomaine)

Founded in 2011, Bite Into Maine is one of the best restaurants in Maine. In Cape Elizabeth, this restaurant has a food truck. Located in Fort Williams Park, Bite into Maine’s food truck is ready to serve you tasty lobster rolls.

Bite the Maine takes lobster rolls to another level. Founders Karl and Sarah Sutton experimented with the traditional lobster roll and made it more brilliant, creative, and modern.

Karl and Sarah thought of adding mayo-flavored ingredients, including wasabi and chipotle. They played with these ingredients to make delectable lobster rolls you can’t get enough of!

Bite the Maine is known for its Maine lobster, lightly dressed with mayonnaise following the classic Maine style. The Maine lobster is in a baked roll and is served cold. If you’re into everything lobster, head out to Bite into Maine.

 

Kettle Cove Creamery and Shack

$ | (207) 747-5909 | WEBSITE

The Kettle Cove Creamery and Shack is a popular restaurant located in Cape Elizabeth, Maine. This restaurant offers delicious ice cream cones, coffee, and your favorite foods!

Kettle Cove Creamery offers homemade ice cream made from milk from local farms. Kettle Cove Creamery has unique flavors, like Birthday Cake Batter, Ginger, Pumpkin Pie, and Health Bar ice cream.

This local creamery opened its doors, emphasizing producing high-quality ice cream using only the best ingredients sourced locally whenever possible. On the other hand, Kettle Cove Shack has fresh lobster clams, burgers, fries, etc.

 

Tacos Y Tequila Cape Elizabeth

$$ | (207) 835-0011 | WEBSITE

Tacos Y Tequila is a Mexican restaurant located in the heart of Cape Elizabeth, Maine. This restaurant serves traditional Mexican food, including nachos, burritos, and quesadillas.  They also have an extensive drink menu with margaritas, cocktails, and mojitos!

If you’re bringing your little ones, they’ll enjoy this place’s kids’ menu. Tacos Y Tequila also offers catering services for any type of event, including business meetings, birthdays, and more.

Tacos Y Tequila Restaurant is located on Ocean House Road in Cape Elizabeth, just up the street from the Kettle Cove Creamery & Shack. If you dine here, make sure to order OMG Nachos, Fajita Quesadilla, and Table-Side Guazamole. These are the top favorites at Tacos Y Tequilla you shouldn’t miss!

 

Tostones Café

$$ | (207) 747-5168 | WEBSITE

Best Restaurant in Cape Elizabeth, ME Tostones Café

Are you craving Latin food? Check out Tostones Café. Tostones Café is a fusion of contemporary Latin cuisine combining the flavors of Tostones with a hint of the Amazon. This restaurant is run by Tostones on the Beach’s owners in Old Orchard Beach.

Tostones Café’s signature menu items include the Campesino, a Mexican coffee sweetened with raw cane sugar, cinnamon, cloves, and anis.

You should also try their Arequipe Café, a milkshake mixed with Mexican coffee and Colombian caramel topped with vanilla ice cream. Their Arepa with Lomo Salta is a must-try, too!

 

Cousins Maine Lobster

$$ | (207) 805-8800 | WEBSITE

Cousins Maine Lobster has been serving the finest seafood and lobster rolls since 1989. The restaurant is located in Captain Strout Circle, Cape Elizabeth, and offers delicious Maine lobster rolls. They have a wide variety of fresh rolls that will surprise your taste buds with unique flavors!

Some of the food Cousins Maine Lobster offers are the Maine Roll and Connecticut Roll. Maine Roll is served chilled and is an all-time favorite of Mainers and tourists alike.

On the other hand, Connecticut Roll is served warmed and is the restaurant’s best seller. Hence, they refer to this as the “heaven on a bun.”

 

C Salt Gourmet Market

$$ | (207) 956-7700 | WEBSITE

Cape Elizabeth, ME Best Restaurants C Salt Gourmet Market

C Salt Gourmet Market has a cafe that offers some of the best food in Cape Elizabeth. Michael and Stephanie Concannon founded this restaurant. While they grew up in Portland, they chose to raise their family in Cape Elizabeth. And so history begins: the birth of C Salt Gourmet Market and its Cafe & Bakery came!

C Salt Market specializes in bringing local products and items from countries worldwide. From coffee to bags of beans and chocolates, there is anything for you.

C Salt Gourmet Market’s Cafe & Bakery has house-made baked goodies prepared by C Salt bakers. They also customized baked creations for their customers.

Whether you’re looking for a nice place to eat for breakfast or start your day with fantastic coffee, C Salt is the place to be!

 

The Cookie Jar

$ | (207) 799-0671 | WEBSITE

The Cookie Jar has been serving up its famous treats since the 1950s when it first opened its doors in Maine. Since then, this bakery has grown and flourished. It is loved by Mainers and tourists alike.

The Cookie Jar crafted original recipes to create sweet delights for everyone. These are handmade with passion, pride, and love for baking. This pastry shop only uses the finest and freshest ingredients because of their utmost attention to quality and taste.

This pastry shop is known for its excellent service and affordable prices. They can make beautiful cakes that will be your party’s center of attraction!

 

The Well at Jordan’s Farm

$$ | (207) 831-9350 | WEBSITE

Located in the seaside town of Cape Elizabeth, The Well at Jordans Farm brings the freshest food right to your table. Interestingly, this restaurant is on 122 acres of farmland. Hence, most of The Well’s menu items and food come from Jordan’s Farm and the neighboring farms in town.

As you wait for your food, you can walk around the farm, explore the beautiful scenery, and sit at their fire pit. It’s a fantastic way to spend time with your friends and family in Maine. You can also pick flowers from their garden in August and September with a small donation.

 

Summary

Cape Elizabeth is known for its fascinating scenery, history, and lighthouses. But you should not miss out on its selection of restaurants!

The best restaurants in Cape Elizabeth, ME, deliver quality ingredients, delicious flavors, and mouthwatering meals. Cape Elizabeth, Maine, is indeed home to a rich history and flavorful gastronomy!

Leave a Comment